Latest DHS Border Policy Could Harm American Economy

The Travel Industry Association (TIA) has expressed concern that new documentation requirements for crossing the U.S.-Canadian border that are scheduled to take effect on January 31, 2008, as part of the Western Hemisphere Travel Initiative (WHTI) could result in significant economic harm. Canadians made more than 40 million visits to the United States in 2006, spending more than $13.5 billion, according to Statistics Canada and the U.S. Dept. of Commerce.

"Canadian travel to America is too important to place at risk," said Roger Dow, president and CEO of the Travel Industry Association. "Just a five percent decline in Canadian visits to the United States could cost the American economy nearly $700 million. At a time when we must stimulate our economy, we cannot afford to implement the Western Hemisphere Travel Initiative in a way that will hinder legitimate border travel without enhancing security."

TIA recently reiterated its support for WHTI, but shares the concern of many in Congress that the proposed policy change has been inadequately communicated and should be reconsidered given the confusion that already exists among travelers in Canada and the United States.

The travel community strongly supports ending the acceptance of oral declarations to enhance security at the border. However, requiring travelers to carry a birth certificate is onerous in the absence of robust, advance outreach to travelers. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) itself has argued that birth certificates are unreliable documents that present verification difficulties for border inspectors. To limit confusion and the threat to commerce, DHS should enhance security by requiring only a government-issued photo ID (such as a current driver's license) until next generation travel documents have been widely adopted and DHS certifies compliance with statutory criteria necessary to transition to full WHTI implementation at land and sea ports of entry after June 2009. Visit (DB)

Suggested Articles

Security concerns in Iranian airspace and a number of new aircraft orders lead this week’s air travel news. Here's what you need to know.

Lindsay Pearlman’s decision to leave Ensemble Travel Group is the latest major executive move this week in the travel industry. Here's what you need to…

New research from IT and services company Vevox tackles dealing with employee ideas. Here's an inside look.